This paper provides an analysis of rudolph ottos understanding of the structures of human consciousness making possible the appropriation of revelation. Aug 20, 2010 kant also contrasts in many interesting ways with aquinas. His first critique seemed to demolish any hope of knowing god, since it portrayed our understanding as limited to phenomena of space and time. For kants moral universalism, contingent religious law is legitimate only when it serves as a means of fulfilling the moral law. Both were convinced that there existed a set of universal laws that could be determined by men and women, and both prized logical reasoning as the key to determining this law. Wood shows that kants sensitive religious outlook on the world deserves to. The philosophy of immanuel kant alfred weber i mmanuel kant,2 born in konigsberg, prussia, 1724, was the son of plain people. Religion and rational theology ebook by immanuel kant. What makes kants philosophy so appealing is his belief in treating people as ends instead of means. For caird, as for fischer, the most natural reading of kant is the holistic one. Judaism and the contingency of religious law in kants. His strictly rational approach was considered so scandalous that the king of prussia forbid him to teach or write further on religious subjects, which kant obeyed until the kings death.
Because of his insistence on the need for an empirical component in knowledge and his antipathy to speculative metaphysics, kant is sometimes presented as a positivist before his time, and his attack upon metaphysics was held by many in his own day to bring both religion and morality down with it. Having been reared in a distinctively religious environment, he remained concerned about the place of religious belief in human thought and action. However, if we take him on his word that he sought to see what can be universally understood by all humanity regarding god with the use of pure reason alone, he in fact advanced our understanding of god. Religion within the bounds of sheer reason kant, wesley. The reasons that kant offers interpret religious trust or commit ment fundamentally as a mode of hope. These passages raise interesting theological questions, but i shall focus on kants general distrust of religious experience. His others works include critique of pure reason and religion within the limits of reason alone. Through this ability the individual is enabled to connect with what is other than the self. Kants promise to the king to refrain from any further writing on religious subjects. Interfaith dialogue and religious education author. As a noun this translates kants ideal, a technical term which he explains in the.
The great gulf if these critics are right, the defects of kants account of reli. I suggest that by reading kant in light of the ideas of the early modern religious rationalists, especially those inspired by the thought of baruch spinoza, one can better explain the radicalization of kants late views on religion, recognized by some contemporary scholars. Pdf kant and the new philosophy of religion researchgate. Professor in the religion and philosophy department.
This entirely new translation of the strange beautiful. Having been reared in a distinctively religious environment, he remained concerned about the place of religious belief in human thought and. Utilitarianism, kantian ethics, natural rights theories. This paper provides analysis of kant s categorical imperative and its relevance to religion. I discuss what the concept of a categorical imperative implies about selftranscendence, and what this understanding of selftranscendence indicates. Religion and rational theology immanuel kant download. His final statement of religion was made after the death of king frederick william ii in 1797. This general observation is the first of four which are appended, one to each book of this work, and which might bear the titles, l works of grace, 2 miracles, 3 mysteries, and 4 means of grace. It represents a great philosophers attempt to spell out the form and content of a type of religion that would be grounded in moral reason and would meet the needs of.
Luther and kant bernard wand it is a commonplaceto say that for kant the claims of morality are both independent of, and more fundamental than, those of religion. Kant s rational theology is revolutionary in that it derives from his critical philosophy. Immanuel kant immanuel kant the critique of practical reason. His paternal grandparents emigrated to germany from the fatherland of hume. The nature of kant s religio us ideas continues to be the subject of philosophical dispute, with viewpoints ranging from the impression that he was an initial advocate of atheism who at some point developed an ontological argument for god, to more critical treatments epitomized by schopenhauer, who criticized the imperative form o f kanti an. Utilitarianism, kantian ethics, natural rights theories, and religious ethics a utilitarian argument, in the strict sense, is one what alleges that we ought to do something because it will produce more total happiness than doing anything else would. Kant and religion, by its topics foremost living scholar, presents the upshot of woods half a century of groundbreaking research on kants engagement with religion, not merely as a topic in metaphysics, but as a major factor in the social and individual dimensions of a moral life. Kant had an answer to the question that bridges the gap between two schools of thought rationalism and empiricism. The name change was announced at a ceremony attended by president vladimir putin of russia and chancellor gerhard schroder of germany, and the university formed a kant society, dedicated to the study of kantianism. For something to be morally good, it isnt enough that it conforms to the moral law.
In his recent article, towards a philosophy of religious pluralism, john hick employs the kantian noumenonphenomenon. Religion rational theology the cambridge edition of. It is thus the text most central to the negative elements of kants philosophy of religion and is integral to the widely held view that kant is hostile to. Pdf while earlier work has emphasized kants philosophy of religion as thinly disguised morality, this timely and original reappraisal of kants. Kants philosophy of religion has perplexed even his warmest admirers. Oneill kant on reason and religion 271 real consolidation to be had, and that we cannot escape the colos sal wreck of rationalist metaphysics and theology and the threat to religious faith. These matters are, as it were, parerga to religion within the limits of pure reason. Kants own theory of knowledge reconfigures the way humans know things. In that work and others, he fleshes out the difference between a constitutive picture of religious concepts and a regulative picture of religious concepts. Kants philosophy of religion in the context of early modern. Religion within the bounds of sheer reason first david hume and then kant asked this question.
The ability to tran scend the self lies at the heart of what it means to be genuinely religious. Nobody has pointed this out more amusingly than hein rich heine, who saw in kant the. The first three correspond to the three critiques and the fourth addresses kant s religion. These works were written during a period of conflict between kant and the prussian authorities over his religious teachings. Chief among these are the moral and the religious import that human beings attribute to the concept of god. In addition, the critical philosophy provided a locus from which kant could address other important dimensions of the concepts of god and religion more explicitly than he had done in his earlier writings. Kant s religion within the boundaries of mere reason is a complex text. This entirely new translation of the critique of pure reason is the most accurate and informative english translation ever produced of this epochal philosophical text. Kant and religion, by its topics foremost living scholar, presents the upshot of woods half a century of groundbreaking research on kant s engagement with religion, not merely as a topic in metaphysics, but as a major factor in the social and individual dimensions of a moral life. Religion within the limits of reason alone by immanuel kant 1793. While earlier work has emphasized kants philosophy of religion as thinly disguised morality, this timely and original reappraisal of kants philosophy of religion incorporates recent scholarship in the philosophy of religion, particularly as it touches questions of phenomenology and christianity. Groundwork immanuel kant preface norm for making correct moral judgments, morality itself will be subject to all kinds of corruption.
Religion within the boundary of pure reason by kant, immanuel, 17241804. Thesamesituationcanalsobesaid aboutaustraliaaswellasmanycountriesineuropeandnorthamerica. Wood argues that kants doctrine of religious belief if consistent with his best critical thinking and, in fact, that the moral argumentsalong with the faith they justifyare an integral part of kants critical philosophy. Immanuel kant was born at konigsberg in east prussia, april 22, 1724. Kants philosophy of religion stanford encyclopedia of. Indeed, kant moves the religious question of the land to the metaphysical moral ground, in which god is a regulative idea assistant to postulate the immortality of the soul which allows men to behave morally. Immanuel kant was a philosopher who critiqued the traditional view of epistemology the study of knowledge and sought a compromise between rationalism and empiricism. Act utilitarianism au is the moral theory that holds that the morally right action, the act. Kant stands out as one secular philosopher who seems to approximate christian ethical beliefs. Evil in human nature natural predisposition not in itself but only as something that moves the will.
Religion within the bounds of bare reason wikipedia. Dicenso has clarified kants position in this easy to read commentary, and by doing so dissolves apparent contradictions and makes sense of kants difficult arguments. Religion within the limits of bare reason immanuel kant belonging to the understanding, which are what we use in thinking about the contingent empirical world. The decision to prohibit kant from writing on religion had been taken by c. Kant and theology philosophy and theology pamela sue. Kants philosophy of religion has both negative and positive components.
Immanuel kant, german philosopher who was one of the foremost thinkers of the enlightenment and who inaugurated a new era of philosophical thought. Ethics rs religious studies revision section covering kantian ethics, immanuel kant, good will and duty, the categorical imperative, the summum bonum, three postulates of pure practical reason, strengths of kantian ethics and weaknesses of kantian ethics. This paper provides analysis of kants categorical imperative and its relevance to religion. Publication date 1838 topics religion philosophy publisher. Sep 30, 2010 immanuel kant was a philosopher who critiqued the traditional view of epistemology the study of knowledge and sought a compromise between rationalism and empiricism. His comprehensive and systematic work in epistemology, ethics, and aesthetics greatly influenced all subsequent philosophy. Kants philosophy of religion stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Although its purpose and original intent has become a matter of some dispute, the books immense and lasting influence on the history of theology and the philosophy of religion is indisputable. Rather than primarily or exclusively relying on human reason or experience to arrive at truth, kant instead sought a philosophical synthesis of these approaches. Already in his dissertation on luthers understanding of the holy spirit, otto was. Religion within the limits of bare reason immanuel kant i. Many think of kants ethical theory in john rawlss apt words not as a morality of austere command but an ethic of mutual. Accepting the latter as a legitimate answer to one troubling antimony, kant derives a critical philosophy which evaluates the notion of religious knowledge. Immanuel kant this volume collects for the first time in a single volume all of kant s writings on religion and rational theology. Kants ethical thought is the direct or indirect source of much that is now standard in normative theories in ethics, political philosophy, and public policy. Biester, editor of the berlinische monatschrijt, had moved his publication to jena to avoid the prussian religious censors.
After pursuing his studies at the university of his native city 17401746, kant became a private tutor. Dicenso has clarified kant s position in this easy to read commentary, and by doing so dissolves apparent contradictions and makes sense of kant s difficult arguments. Kants philosophy is generally designated as a system of transcendental criticism tending towards agnosticism in theology, and favoring the view that christianity is a nondogmatic religion. Rather than saying that people are all passive perceivers observing the world, kant believed that humans are active in. In 2005, the university was renamed immanuel kant state university of russia. It is understandable that kant should judge religious experience harshly. This volume collects for the first time in a single volume all of kants writings on religion and rational theology. Kants philosophy of religion in the context of early. Religion within the boundaries of mere reason is a key element of the system of philosophy which kant introduced with his critique of pure reason, and a work of major importance in the history of western religious thought. Though kant uses traditional theological resources to account for the possibility of statutory ecclesiastical law in historical religions, he denies this possibility to jewish law.
Apr 18, 2020 immanuel kant, german philosopher who was one of the foremost thinkers of the enlightenment and who inaugurated a new era of philosophical thought. He casts aside the notion of prayer as a way of communing with a god, whose will we may discern and from whom we may receive revelation. Inquiries into the validity of religious truth claims and the possible meanings of religious writings and images form a vital part of kants ethical and political. The great gulf if these critics are right, the defects of kants account of reli gion are symptoms of wider problems in his philosophy. Since this is possible only when the free will incorporates such moral feeling into its maxim, the constitution of such a will is good character. Kant s philosophy is best thought of as a work in progress. Kant on reason and religion the tanner lectures on human. Immanuel kant the critique of practical reason britannica. After an initial overview discussion of kants philosophy of religion, this entry will. Pdf the religious a priori in otto and its kantian origins. The historical context and progression of this conflict are charted in the general introduction to the volume and in the translators introductions to. This is a crucial text, if we wish to understand the role of historical faith in kants explicitly religious writings, for in the foregoing passage kant is referring only to the. Another influential translation, friedrich paulsens kant, was published in 1902.
Pdf the religious a priori in otto and its kantian. Kant is not a theologian, but religion is exposed in all his philosophical work, the prolegomena to the peace project, but none directly addresses that kant in religion within the limits of reason. Kant on politics, religion, and secularism pontifical academy of. He is quite right that the text avails itself, if not quite of every thing, still of too much. Kants liberal secularism though kant may be considered the most prestigious father of liberal. Kants religion within the boundaries of mere reason is a complex text.
Utilitarianism, kantian ethics, natural rights theories, and. It is extremely wellwritten, clear, concise, and full of helpful examples. Pontifical academy of social sciences, acta 17, 2012. In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content religious concepts and moral theory. Kant and aquinas were, in my opinion, men of similar thought. Collins here captures a more complete sense of kants religious emphasis on a moral kingdom under. In the centuries prior to kant, contemporary philosophy had been moving away from the virtue ethics of plato and.
Hence, as we will discuss through this entry, the statement that kant sought out the limits to knowledge wissen in order to make room for faith glaube bxxx, is not an empty bromide, but rather the key anthem for his overall philosophy of religion. Kant and theology is a welcome addition to the undergraduate classroom, and should not be missed by instructors seeking to help students identify and understand central issues in philosophy and philosophy of religion. Immanuel kant 17241804 focused on elements of the philosophy of religion for about half a centuryfrom the mid1750s, when he started teaching philosophy, until after his retirement from academia. In his 1794 book, religion within the limits of reason alone, kant rejects religious experience as fanatical. If kant is read as limiting reason to make room for faith in the sense of partitioning knowledge, he would have done christianity a disservice.
901 868 892 495 632 358 1523 70 21 1370 152 392 224 909 1180 405 465 482 146 1330 116 839 670 1177 359 577 1063 1354 676 400 889 1231 1485 1213 579 931 586 579 332 523 1061