For those of us who have written about terrorism over the decades there is a sense of weariness. This paper explores the relationship between terrorism and human rights. State actors in an international definition of terrorism from a human rights perspective bruce broomhallt i. In order to right the wrongs of the government, citizens may turn to terrorism. Other examples of state terrorism may include the world war ii bombings of pearl harbor, london, dresden, chongqing, and hiroshima an act of sabotage, sometimes regarded as an act of terrorism, was the. In war on terror, many countries violating human rights standards, third committee told committee hears reports concerning torture, human rights defenders, countering terrorism, freedom of. Counterterrorism is a human rights issue because the way that the state responds to the threat of terrorism may involve exceptional measures that depart. This positive obligation fully justifies statesfight against terrorism.
The obligation to respect and ensure, nondiscrimination and the right to judicial protection. Country reports on terrorism 2017 is submitted in compliance with title 22 of the united states code, section 2656f the act, which requires the department of state to provide to congress a full and complete annual report on terrorism for those countries and groups meeting the criteria of the act. Terrorism has slammed and affected almost every sphere of human life, be it economy or politics or social life, whatever. State counterterrorist measures implicate nume ous fundamental human rights, r including the right to. Yet, the term is so loaded with conceptual problems that a totally accepted definition of it still does not exist. This provision enables a state to unilaterally derogate from some of its obligations to the european convention on human rights in certain exceptional circumstances and has been used by certain member states in the context of terrorism1. No to terrorism, yes to human rights human rights watch.
The suspected perpetrators of attacks also have rights, as fellow human beings, in the course of their apprehension and prosecution. Terrorism and the european convention on human rights. However, article 15 can be used to override articles 5 and 6 in certain circumstances which means articles can conflict at times. Report on terrorism and human rights executive summary. The european response to terrorism in an age of human rights. United states and statesponsored terrorism wikipedia. Rights to due process and to a fair trial and terrorism e. Watson routledge, mar 5, 20 political science 182 pages. This chapter develops a principled approach to resolving the conflict arising between the need for national security and human rights based on the doctrine of proportionality. Pdf james igoe walsh is an associate professor in the political science department at the university of north carolina at charlotte. The impact of terrorism on human rights masterarbeit. It is therefore argued that one way to hold terrorists responsible is to qualify their acts as crimes against humanity. United states department of state bureau of democracy, human rights and labor. Obligation to respect and ensure, nondiscrimination and the right to judicial protection iv.
Selected literature on human rights and terrorism jstor. Lack of transparency and oversight mechanisms 48 ii. State actors in an international definition of terrorism. Human rights and terrorism johns hopkins university. When a state has very low respect for human rights, the citizens are more likely to have grievances with those in charge. Security, terrorism and human rights by joanne mariner terrorism is not a new problem, nor is there anything novel in the government tendency to justify repressive policies by reference to the. Guidelines on human rights and the fight against terrorism. Annex i iachr resolution on terrorism and human rights. Terrorism and the european convention on human rights article 15 derogation in time of an emergency of the european convention on human rights. While counterterrorist measures are essential for states to maintain.
In time of war or other public emergency threatening the life of the. Nazi germany and the soviet union under stalins rule are frequently cited as historical cases of state terrorism. Fighting terrorism means stripping statesponsored terrorists of their impunity and bringing them to justice pinochet, and yes, henry kissinger. Office of the united nations high commissioner for human rights ohchr. According to the international law, torture that is sometimes carried out by terrorism organizations is a violation to the international law as well as by states which use torture. Security of the individual is a basic human right and the protection of individuals is, accordingly, a fundamental obligation of government. While states claim a monopoly on the legitimate use of violence, in that they claim the right to resort to violence. Human rights and terrorism icelandic human rights centre. International counterterrorism bodies and human rights inputs 34 iv.
Human rights european journal of international law. The irony is that the recurrent theme of terrorism has become the daily. Counterterrorism, human rights and the rule of law. However, it is debatable whether human rights law could and should apply to acts of terrorists, as such acts are perpetrated mostly by nonstate actors. First, we strongly affirm that terrorism is an awful crime that can never be excused or justified. It poses a major threat to human rights, beginning with the most fundamental of rights, the right. Report on terrorism and human rights table of contents.
Pdf on jan 1, 2012, ruth blakeley and others published state violence as state terrorism find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Dimaya based on the antiterrorism bill the term terrorism is defined as the use of violence or other destructive means to create public panic or individual fear or to force or scare the government from doing certain acts. Paper presented at the esil forum in the workshop on human rights under threat on 27. In the shadow of 911 the threat of terrorism is an ever increasing global preoccupation.
The right to freedom of expression and terrorism f. These state that everyone has the right to liberty and security of person and a right to a fair trial respectively. In the 20th century, authoritarian states systematically committed to using violence and extreme versions of threat against their own civilians exemplify the premise of state terrorism. Terrorism is a human rights issue because it involves deliberate attacks on civilians causing death and serious injury and so engages the right to life and the right to physical integrity. As of december 23, terrorism fatalities stood at 686, in comparison with 1,260 total fatalities in 2017, a ccording to the south asia terrorism portal, a database compiled by the publicinterest advocacy organization.
In broad sense, the terrorism is the antithesis of independence and the independence is meaningless without the human rights. Practical guidance paper oncounterterrorism and human rights 2012. Human rights, terrorism and counterterrorism ohchr. Counterterrorism, human rights and the rule of law in africa introduction we are now well into the second decade since the 911 attacks in 2001 so vividly placed transnational terrorism on the international agenda. Guidelines on human rights and the fight against terrorism adopted by the committee of ministers on 11 july 2002 at the 804th meeting of the ministers deputies isbn 9287150214. The innocent victims of terrorism suffer an attack on their most basic right to live in peace and security. Perhaps in no other area is there greater convergence between international human rights law and international humanitarian law than in the standards of humane treatment and respect for human dignity. It is addressed to state authorities, national and international nongovernmental organizations ngos, national human rights institutions. We must respond resolutely to terrorism without compromising human rights. Fighting terrorism means shining a light into the darkest corners of human existence, and bringing a real promise of human rights to all the worlds people, so that desperate men and women. Terrorism and human rights introduction the september 11 2001 tragedy has again revived debate over the need to combat international terrorism. Sco compliance with the international framework for promotion and protection of human rights 39 a. Nothing in this declaration may be interpreted as implying for any state, group or person any right to engage in any activity or to perform any act aimed at the destruction of any of the rights and freedoms set forth herein. Terrorism and human rights discusses the effects of the legal and social aspects of terrorism by examining the relation between security issues and human rights from the angle of international organizations, political bodies and different countries.
Pdf state violence as state terrorism researchgate. Balancing human rights and national security oxford. Most of the worst attacks in europe have been carried out by individuals who live, work and have their families in europe. States therefore have an obligation to ensure the human rights of their nationals and others by taking positive measures to protect them against the threat of.
Counterterrorism and the protection of human rights. The united states has at various times in recent history provided support to terrorist and paramilitary organizations around the world. Other delegations have suggested including forms of. Within this broader context, the volume has a number of specific aims. National strategy for combating terrorism focuses on identifying and defusing threats before they reach our borders. Terrorism and the european conv ention on hu man rights. Terrorism and human rights role of the security personnel and the police. Human rights are relevant to terrorism as concerns both its victims and its perpetrators.
While we appreciate the nature of the difficult challenge before us, our strategy is based on the belief that sometimes the most difficult tasks are accomplished by the most direct means. Military actions primarily directed against noncombatant targets have also been referred to as state terrorism. The interamerican commission on human rights, as the oas organ charged with promoting the observance and protection of human rights in the hemisphere, has since its creation in 1959 gained extensive experience in evaluating the human rights implications of numerous antiterrorist initiatives undertaken. Also, a states failure to adhere to fundamental human rights norms makes it more. The right to life is a fundamental human right which is not only violated by terrorist organizations but also some state agencies in their counter terrorism efforts.
For example, the bombing of guernica has been called an act of terrorism. Today, both the world at large and india in particular, face daunting challenges in the task of protecting human rights of common people regardless of the country they belong to. International responses since the end of the cold war gillian duncan, orla lynch, gilbert ramsay, alison m. This factsheet does not bind the court and is not exhaustive. Contemporary state terrorism this volume aims to bring the state back into terrorism studies and fill the notable gap that currently exists in our understanding of the ways in which states employ terrorism as a political strategy of internal governance or foreign policy. This book poses critical questions about the definition of terrorism, the role of human rights and the push by many governments for more security powers. Osce, countering terrorism, protecting human rights, a manual 2007. Terrorism is an evergrowing threat to world security. War on terrorism and respect for human rights swiss franc euro change currency since the beginning of this new millennium, terms such as terrorist, terrorism, fight against terrorism, etc. Annex ii table of oas member state participation in human rights.
735 443 1035 696 1507 25 550 1361 1468 1386 452 1535 1126 1106 168 504 1260 227 1430 236 394 659 565 1562 425 193 1142 1487 1293 672 776 744 153